Competitive Compass Competitive Compass Signal for Financial Leaders
Competitive Compass
Competitive Compass
Signal for Financial Leaders
Issue No. 321
Wednesday, September 16, 2026·4 minute read

The Audience
Bought the Ad.

Andrew and I were there as guests. Everyone else had bought a ticket, starting at $100.
Anuj Shahani and Andrew at Citi and Mastercard's The Curated Table, The Shed, Hudson Yards
Citi and Mastercard’s The Curated Table at The Shed, Hudson Yards.

Activations in traditional marketing speak have always gone over my head.

This past week I got an immersive one, twice. Thank you to Citi and Mastercard for New York Fashion Week at The Shed, and to Equifax at the US Open. Christian Siriano opened his ateliers and staged a show. Michael and Bryan Voltaggio cooked. At the US Open, the grounds were full of lounges, bars, games, and giveaways from banks, hotels, car companies, and wellness brands, and people queued for all of them.

I had an incredible time at both. So I got curious about 2 things.

1
What does a brand actually get from an activation?
2
Why do they seem to be happening so much more often now?

The second one is easy to answer. Look at the money. Companies spent $138.94 billion on brand experiences worldwide last year, up 8.3%. American companies spent $64.43 billion of that, close to half the world’s money in a country with about 4% of the world’s population. PQ Media expects another 10.3% this year.

The first question took me longer, and I got the answer from something I noticed at dinner. Andrew and I were there as guests. Everyone else had bought a ticket, starting at $100.

The takeaway

Your customer now buys admission to your marketing.
Then they outspend everyone who stayed home.

In This Edition
01
Dining spend grew 95%
02
Gen Z wants in
03
Business experiences grow faster
04
Lessons from outside financial services
05
Steelman This
06
Predictions for 2027
Citi 2026 Investor Day, US Consumer Cards

Citi’s dining program spend grew 95% between 2022 and 2025

Customers who use the dining program spend 3.7x what everyone else spends.

The same deck carries the rest of the story. Strata new accounts grew 38% in 2025. Spend per account grew about 14% against 2022. The lifetime value Citi books on each new account grew about 20%. And 98% of customers keep the account.

Exhibit 1
Dining grew 95% between 2022 and 2025, the fastest of Citi’s 4 lifestyle programs
Growth in program spend, 2025 against 2022. Dining program users spend 3.7x what other customers spend, measured across 2025.
Source: Citi 2026 Investor Day, US Consumer Cards presentation, slides 8, 9 and 10. Rewards growth measured as value of points redeemed. Travel, dining and shopping measured as program spend.

The newest program of the four grew the fastest, and it is the one built around a table.

Loyalty on Gen Z’s Terms

77% of Gen Z want their bank to get them into events and experiences

Cardmembers buy Curated Table tickets from $100, on top of the $595 they already pay each year for the card.

Look at who is buying. Citi grew its share of new accounts from Millennials and Gen Z by 4%, and its share of new accounts earning over $150,000 by 6%. That is the aspirational customer, and aspirational customers spend on going out. Bank of America sees the same thing in its own card data. Gen Z spent nearly 7% more at restaurants this July than last, about double what Millennials did, and they were the only generation spending more at every kind of restaurant.

Higher-income households outspend lower-income households by about 14 points on airlines and about 8 on hotels, the two widest gaps Bank of America measured. People with money spend it on going places.

Exhibit 2
Gen Z ranks getting into events level with having 1 bank for everything
The generation growing fastest in your book is asking for access.
Source: Loyalty on Gen Z’s Terms by Marisa Frys, Mintel. Generational restaurant figures from Bank of America Institute, Restaurants: What’s cooking in consumer spending?, August 24, 2026. Income gaps from Bank of America Institute, Consumer Checkpoint, August 11, 2026. Ticket pricing from Citi and Mastercard, September 2026.
Worth asking

Our customers buy tickets to concerts, dinners, and trips all year. What would they buy a ticket to from us?

PQ Media, Experiential Marketing Forecast

Experiences built for business customers grew 9.7% in 2025

My Tuesday came courtesy of Equifax at the US Open, and that is the other half of this market. It is the half growing faster.

Exhibit 3
B2B experiences grew 9.7% in 2025, faster than the consumer half at 7.7%
Source: PQ Media, Global B2C and B2B Experiential Marketing Forecast, June 2026. Global totals for 2025. US Open sponsor count from SportsPro, August 2026.

A day like that buys time. A senior buyer gives the host most of a day by choice, in a good mood. Sales teams learn more in those hours than in a year of email, and the next conversation starts warm.

Plenty of brands reached the same conclusion. 31 sponsored the tournament this year. Last year, 21 did.

Worth asking

Our best client relationships took years to build. Which of next year’s relationships could start with a single day together?

Lessons from outside financial services

Brand and settingWhat they builtThe resultWhat a bank can build
Spotify WrappedA customer’s own year turned into something worth posting, extended into around 50 installations and pop-ups across more than 30 markets200 million engaged users in the first 24 hours, over 500 million sharesGive the customer their year back in a form they want to show people
Gap, CoachellaHoodie House, where guests customized a $100 hoodie with patches, beads and charmsOver 1 million content views, about 35% above target, search interest up around 5,000%Let guests make the thing they take home, then let them wear it
Grey Goose, US OpenA single signature cocktail, served the same way each year since 2007, inside a 20 year partnership738,459 servings at $23, close to $17 million, up 32%Own a ritual guests come back for, and let it earn revenue on the day
IHG, US OpenA free premium coach home after late matches, with pizza, charging and match replays on boardFree rides to 2 central Manhattan hotels through the first roundsFix the moment in the customer’s day that actually hurts
Always and Secret, CoachellaClean, well staffed facilities on the festival grounds, built from the brands’ own researchAnswered the need 57% of women named a top priorityStart from your own customer research, then build the fix people feel
The common thread is a guest who goes home with something of their own.
Sources: Spotify Newsroom and Music Week, Wrapped 2025. Glossy and SponsorUnited, Coachella 2026. Sportico, Honey Deuce sales, 2025 tournament. Event Marketer, US Open 2026 activation coverage. Procter and Gamble, Always and Secret research among 2,000 US women.
Worth asking

Our customers already trust us with their money. What would we hand them back at the end of the year that they would actually want to post?

Steelman This
3 reasons an activation may suit somebody else better than you

I intend to put this block in every edition. Intellectual honesty means I argue the other side of my own case as hard as I can, so you can make a fair assessment of what works best for your own products.

1. The reach is tiny. A dinner seats a few hundred. A campaign reaches millions. Judge an activation on depth per guest, then compare that to what the same money buys you in media.

2. The best number in this edition is a correlation. Citi’s 3.7x compares people who enrolled against everybody else, and high spenders enroll in things. A matched test would tell you how much of that 3.7x the program itself created.

3. Your product has to suit the format. An evening works when the product is discretionary, emotional, and social. A checking account bought on rate gets very little from a runway show, and the money does more in a rate table.

My honest answer. A paid experience works for customers who already have money and already go out. That is the upper slope of the K-shaped economy. Applying it to the lower slope would take real changes. Aspiration exists down there too, and the constraints are much heavier.

Predictions for 2027

Prediction 01
As experiences get more popular, some marketing expense converts into revenue and loyalty

Citi sells Curated Table tickets from $100. A Manhattan hotel started ballroom tennis at $1,500 this summer. Grey Goose sold 738,459 cocktails at $23. Each of those does two jobs at once: it funds production and fills seats with people who chose to be there and stay loyal afterward. I keep thinking about how Bezos would look at this cost and work out how to turn it into revenue.

Watch for the first issuer to describe event revenue in an earnings call as income rather than expense.

Prediction 02
Banks start judging an event by the 12 months of spending that follow it

Citi published 3.7x. Nobody yet knows how much of that the dining program created and how much came from the kind of customer who joins a dining program. One test settles it. Take the people who came, take a similar group who stayed home, and compare what each group spends over the next 12 months. Banks already own both sides of that data.

Watch for the first bank to publish that comparison. Whoever goes first sets the number everybody else gets measured against.

Prediction 03
The dining platforms issuers already own start selling tickets

Issuers spent 5 years buying the places people book a table.

Watch for the first issuer to sell tickets to its own event on a platform it already owns.

Jul 2019
American Express
Resy
Dec 2020
Chase
cxLoyalty
Sep 2021
Chase
The Infatuation and Zagat
Jun 2023
Capital One
Velocity Black
Jun 2024
American Express
Tock and Rooam, $400 million
Source: company announcements, July 2019 to June 2024.
For issuers

Put on your own event, charge for the seat, then count what those guests spend with you over the next year.

Companies put $138.94 billion into brand experiences last year, chasing customers who already moved on. Citi built an evening, sold tickets from $100, and filled it. 77% of Gen Z want their bank to do exactly that. The audience bought the ad, and that changes what marketing is for.

As ever,
Anuj
Anuj Shahani
Anuj Shahani
VP, Comperemedia
ashahani@openbrand.com ·New York, NY
You are receiving this as part of a community of 17,000 financial services leaders shaping the industry’s future. Reply anytime. I read every response.
Forward this newsletter or sign a colleague up
Subscribe